TURTLES ALL THE WAY DOWN by John Green | Review

How do I even begin this review of John Green’s long-awaited novel Turtles All the Way Down? If ever a book was at risk to be threatened by high expectations and hype, then this would certainly be the one. Like many avid readers of Green’s works, I was both eager and anxious to read this latest release. I couldn’t help but wonder how it would compare to his other novels and his writing would still strike chords with me as it did when I first read Paper Towns and Looking for Alaska back in middle school. More than anything, I was afraid of being disappointed. My inner Nerdfighter desperately wanted John Green to remain the gifted storyteller that I have always viewed him as being.

Ah, Holly of the past. Shouldn’t you have learned by now not to doubt John Green? As per usual, I needn’t have worried: I ended up reading Turtles All the Way Down in a single afternoon because I was so caught up in the story.

My worries that I would be less able to relate to characters who are still in high school crumbled upon reading the very first page. As much as we’d like to believe otherwise, I think we’re all still a bit like our high school selves on the inside— at the very least, I can easily put myself back in my sixteen-year-old self’s shoes (made even more easy by the fact that they’re the same size as the ones I wear now) and remember feeling intensely awkward, stressed, insecure, and confused. Although my life is significantly different from that of Aza, the protagonist, I found myself quickly empathizing with her many conflicting emotions.

People often talk about how the young adult genre is apparently silly and shameful for adults to read. In her now infamous Slate article “Against YA,” Ruth Graham denounces YA literature by claiming that  “the enjoyment of reading this stuff has to do with escapism, instant gratification, and nostalgia.” These motivations for reading YA literature– or any genre of literature, for that matter– may exist, but I would argue that they are certainly not the only reasons adults have for reading books like Turtles All the Way Down. Reading about characters who lively wholly different lifestyles requires empathy, a skill that some readers clearly must not possess if they cannot see the immense value in reading YA literature. In a novel such as Turtles in which the protagonist struggles with overwhelming Obsessive Compulsive Disorder while simultaneously navigating her tumultuous teenage years, empathy is an essential key to understanding and growing from the reading experience.

Once that personal hurdle was crossed, the next aspect of the novel that struck me was John Green’s telltale writing style. Let me just say thatadore his writing style no matter how over-the-top, pretentious, and cheesy it may be at times. Whenever someone points out grandiose Augustus-Waters-esque dialogue to me, I can’t help but insist that that is precisely the point. I would certainly hope (and firmly believe) that John Green doesn’t actually think or expect all teenagers to speak like they’re in some sort of dramatic production. I think this somewhat pompous speech is Green’s way of emphasizing that teenagers are fully capable of being intelligent, intellectual, thoughtful people despite the media’s often negative portrayal of them. Take the following passage for example:

“We never really talked much or even looked at each other, but it didn’t matter because we were looking at the same sky together, which is maybe even more intimate than eye contact anyway. I mean, anybody can look at you. It’s quite rare to find someone who sees the same world you see.”

Is this cheesy? Yes. Is it true? Also yes. This is why I admire Green as a writer: he takes the time to delve into the little truths that so many writers skip over because they are supposedly too obvious, petty, or insignificant to be mentioned. As a fellow meticulous bookworm, I appreciate Green’s attention to detail. 

Of course, I could not write a sufficient review of Turtles without applauding Green’s intense, genuine, remarkable representation of mental health issues. Aza, like the writer who created her, lives with OCD. While I am fortunate to not also struggle with this particular disorder, I have experienced plenty of anxiety. I cannot begin to describe how refreshing it was to read about a character who is not the “perfectly imperfect” girl we all for some reason aspire to be; instead, Aza is flawed in a way that most of us will never be able to understand from our own personal experiences. At times Green’s descriptions of Aza’s obsessive spirals were nearly anxiety-inducing in themselves, which is a testament to the raw honesty of this novel.

Overall, Turtles All the Way Down made me laugh, think, and remember why I continue to be an avid reader of John Green’s books. If you’re searching for a novel that will simultaneously captivate you with its characters and plot and move you with its genuine truth, then look no further!

What are your thoughts on Turtles All the Way Down? Do you have a favorite John Green book? Let me know in the comments section below!



35 thoughts on “TURTLES ALL THE WAY DOWN by John Green | Review

  1. To be honest, I sort of “lost” the spark in reading John Green novels since his long hiatus between The Fault in Our Stars and this book. That’s why when it came to the release of Turtles, I practically ignored it and lost interest whatsoever. I might pick it up someday – your review actually got me interested all of a sudden.

    As for my favourite John Green novel, it’s got to be An Abundance of Katherines. Just loads of fun and laughter all around!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. If you enjoyed John Green’s other novels then I would definitely recommend reading Turtles– it has the same John Green vibe but deals with a much more interesting and personal topic. (And Abundance of Katherines is such a great choice!!)


  2. I completely agree with your post. I think you either love him or hate him. I also think people who state he writes in a way that makes young adults appear far older in their thoughts are wrong. Young adults aren’t stupid. They are capable of thinking deep thoughts. Those are the years that you are trying to figure out who you are and what you want out of life… if that’s not intelligent, thoughtful, or deep then I don’t know what is. I love that he deals with real life situations as opposed to the cliche topics that all people think teens are going through. I love how his characters have major faults that will most likely carry through to their adulthood. I loved this story but I have to say looking for Alaska will always be my fave. Thanks for the post!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I always love John Green’s character!! I don’t know how he makes them feel so realistic and multifaceted…. that’s what I struggle with most when I attempt to write fiction. It’s so hard!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Yes, yes, yes. I agree wholeheartedly with everything in this review. John Green’s over-the-top writing style is what I live for😍 and I do agree that I think the characters’ dialogue isn’t meant to be 100% realistic, it’s more to represent the point that teenagers have the capacity to think deeply.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. AHHH this is such a wonderful review! I’m SO EXCITED to read this book. I struggle with panic disorder, so I always appreciate it when a YA book explores an anxiety disorder.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I agree with you about Green’s depiction of “unrealistic” teenage dialogue. In some ways, I think it’s more true than we give him credit for. I actually think a lot of teenagers think this way, at least about the big things in life. Read a teenager’s journal, and you’ll probably get a whole bunch of grandiose thoughts. Everything in life feels more intense at that age!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s