P.S. I STILL LOVE YOU by Jenny Han | Review

I did it: I actually continued on with a series! It’s been quite some time since I’ve actually followed through with a series, mostly because I just didn’t have the time because of all my coursework. But the summer was the best time to catch up on all of my reading, and I ended up being able to listen to this trilogy on audiobook.

For the most part, I really liked this second installment in Lara Jean’s story—perhaps even more than the first book. In P.S. I Still Love You we get to see a new side of Lara Jean where she isn’t afraid to stand up to the boy she thinks she loves when she feels like she isn’t valued and shown the same love in return. I really liked the scene where she puts her foot down with Peter and tells him how his ongoing friendship with Genevieve makes her feel. Maybe it’s because I haven’t read much Young Adult fiction in a while, but you don’t tend to see intense breakups like that in books like these.

I loved that so many friends from Lara Jean’s past come back into play, especially John. John might be my new favorite character in this series, although Kitty is a hard one to beat. He’s such a caring, thoughtful guy and genuinely wants what is best for Lara Jean. The scene with the time capsule in the treehouse was adorable, albeit tense because of the Lara Jean-Genevieve dynamic. Jenny Han does a great job capturing what it feels like to reminisce with old friends, to experience the ebbs and flows of friendship over the years. Sometimes the pull is strong and sometimes outside circumstances (different schools, different jobs, different locations, different schedules) make it harder for friends to see each other. And, most importantly, friendships change. Throughout this book, Lara Jean’s feelings towards Genevieve are a clear reminder of that fact. I love reading about family dynamics, but I’m starting to realize that I might even love reading about friendships even more.

And don’t get me started on the assisted living home scenes—they were the best. Not only did we get to see Lara Jean outside of the context of her family and friends, but Stormy and her elderly pals added thought-provoking depth and perspective to this story that you don’t often find in Young Adult fiction. It’s easy to get swept up in the drama and minutiae of Lara Jean’s high school problems. While they are obviously important in the moment and their significance should not be undermined, Stormy reminds Lara Jean that someday she may look back on this time in her life as a story, and obstacle she overcame and that taught her enough to view it fondly in her memory. And I love the thought of that.

What I did not love was the ending of this book. To be honest, Peter looks like a complete @$$hole in this book and the fact that Lara Jean makes the decision she does at the very end was incredibly frustrating. Can’t she see that her other option is so much better? Then again, haven’t we all gone back to what is familiar and known at some point in our lives, even against our better judgement? It’s understandable but frustrating that Lara Jean makes this decision. But I can’t say it also isn’t one that I haven’t made myself.

Overall, I enjoyed P.S. I Still Love You more than I thought I would (up until the ending…) and am really looking forward to seeing where Jenny Han goes with the third book. So much could happen! If you’ve read To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before and are wondering whether or not to continue on with the rest of the series, I would highly recommend it.

What are your thoughts on this book and series in general? Have you seen the movie adaptation? Let me know in the comments section below!



5 responses to “P.S. I STILL LOVE YOU by Jenny Han | Review”

  1. Fantastic review, Holly! I totally agree with everything you’ve written about this one. John is such a good guy and I loved the assisted living home scenes too. Stormy was as wonderful as John and I loved all their interactions and imparted wisdom lol I also totally wasn’t feeling Peter in this one. It’ll be interesting to see how they adapt this one for the movie! Can’t wait to hear what you think of the last book in the series 🙂


  2. I AM NOT ALONE! I felt like the ONLY person who really thought Peter was an ***hole throughout this book. To be fair, I was meh about him in book one. But THIS ONE???? I was FURIOUS with him! I wanted her to end up with the other guy ha-ha!

    Lovely review, darlin’!


  3. I’ve seen the movie so many times hehehe


  4. Marta @ the book mermaid Avatar
    Marta @ the book mermaid

    Wonderful review! I completely agree that, similar to the first book, this one offers great family and friendship dynamics and it was good to see Lara Jean standing up for things, but that ending was really frustating. However, I’ve enjoyed the third book a lot, and I hope you do too ^^


  5. Wonderful review, love!! I actually haven’t read these books yet, but I adore the movie. It’s so great to hear that LJ develops so much as a character throughout this one! I’m sorry to see that Peter turns out to be such an ass at times. Hopefully his character will improve in the third book then! ❤


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: